John Alemi (Forward) -- 1st Team (2013) 

Christian "Chich" Ball*** (Forward) -- 2nd Team (2018), 1st Team (2019), 1st Team (2020), 1st Team (2021)* 

Jon Baxter (GK) -- 2nd Team (2013), 2nd Team (2014), 1st Team (2015) 

Luke Baxter (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2018) 

Rich Bond (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2015) 

Gabriel DaSilva (Defender) -- 2nd Team (2016) 

Sam DeCencio (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2016)*, 1st Team (2017)* 

Steve DiTomaso (Forward) -- 2nd Team (2017), 1st Team (2018) 

Jack Dugan** (Forward) -- 1st Team (2014), 1st Team (2015), 1st Team (2016)*, 1st Team (2017)* 

Wyatt Dugan (Forward) -- 1st Team (2015) 

Cole Fabbri (Defender) -- 1st Team (2014), 1st Team (2015)* 

Connor Fell (Midfield) -- 2nd Team (2019) 

Matt Fell (Forward) -- 1st Team (2015)* 

Max Green (Defender) -- 1st Team (2017) 

Andrew Guveiyian (Forward) -- 1st Team (2022), 1st Team (2023)* 

Henry Hall (Defender) – 2nd Team (2024)

Billy Impagliazzo (Defender) -- 2nd Team (2020) 

Eric Kaulback (Defender) -- 1st Team (2013) 

Geno Mariano (Forward) -- 1st Team (2019) 

Michael McCool (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2023), 1st Team (2024)* 

Alessandro Meucci (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2020) 

Finn Miller (GK) -- 1st Team (2017)* 

Tommy Mollis (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2018)*, 1st Team (2019)* 

Matthew Murschell (Midfield) -- 2nd Team (2022) 

Brady Norton (GK) -- 2nd Team (2022) 

Andrew O'Donnell (Defender) -- 1st Team (2022) 

Luke Pease (Midfield) -- 1st Team (2013)* 

Cole Roddy (Defender) -- 1st Team (2019)* 

Daire Roddy (Defender) -- 1st Team (2021), 1st Team (2022), 1st Team (2023) 

Jack Walters (Midfield) -- 2nd Team (2023) 

Auden Yowler (Defender) -- 1st Team (2021)*

*BOLD - Top Vote-Winner (by position) 

**Only Player in HMHS Boys Soccer History Designated 4-Time 1st Team All-Conference 

***Second Player since 2013 to Earn All-Conference Designation 4-Straight Seasons